Allen McDonald Swartz Partners, Fraser McDonald, Henry Bertossi and Jillian Swartz Act for TCI Fund Management in Connection with its Activist Campaign Relating to Canadian National Railway Company

CN Settles With TCI After Failed Railroad Deal
By Ronald Orol
March 22nd, 2022 By Ronald Orol
Published in The Deal (

The Canadian railway company is bringing on a new CEO and will install two new directors under an agreement with Chris Hohn’s activist fund.

Canadian National Railway Co. (CNI) on Jan. 25 said it settled with TCI Fund Management Ltd.’s Chris Hohn in a deal that will add two mutually agreed upon directors as the railroad installed a new CEO.
CN said in a release that it’s installing Tracy Robinson as president and CEO, effective Feb. 28. Robinson is executive vice president and president of Canadian natural gas pipelines at TC Energy Corp. (TRP). She previously spent 27 years at rival Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd. (CP), including various executive roles.

In addition, Canadian National Railway is adding Jean Charest, a former conservative premier of the province of Quebec between 2003 and 2012, as a director.

As part of the deal with TCI, CN agreed to bring on two new yet-to-be-named additional directors by no later than CN’s 2022 annual meeting, expected in April.

Robinson will replace outgoing CEO Jean-Jacques Ruest, who moved to step down in October under pressure from TCI.

Following the new CEO installation and director agreement, TCI agreed to cancel a minority-slate director contest it had been waging as part of a campaign arguing that CN’s $34 billion failed bid last year to buy Kansas City Southern “exposed a basic misunderstanding” of the railroad industry and regulatory environment.

Kansas City Southern agreed to sell to CP in September for $27.3 billion after canceling its deal with CN. The CN deal failed after the main U.S. railroad regulator, the Surface Transportation Board, on Aug. 31 rejected its proposal to employ a voting trust agreement for its transaction.

TCI isn’t the only activist targeting Canadian National Railway. The Wall Street Journal reported in October that Elliott Management Corp. had acquired a large stake in CN and supported TCI’s efforts. The Paul Singer-led fund had been in talks with CN for weeks, the report added. TCI owns about 5% of CN and 8.4% of Canadian Pacific.

Hohn had been seeking to remove board chairman Robert Pace and install his own candidate, Jim Vena, who previously served in executive and senior positions at both Union Pacific Corp. (UNP) and CN, as the next CEO.

Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP partners Walied Soliman, Trevor Zeyl and Stephen Kelly; Torys LLP nonexecutive chair Robert Prichard and partner John Emanoilidis; Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz partners Steven Cohen and Jenna Levine; and Stikeman Elliott LLP partner Jean Marc Huot provided legal advice to CN.

CN received financial advice from JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s David Freedman and Chris Ventresca as well as Royal Bank of Canada.

TCI received legal advice from Fasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP partners Bradley Freelan, Neil Kravitz, Brad Moore, Taisha Lewis and Brandon Farber; Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP partner Eleazer Klein; and Allen McDonald Swartz LLP partners Fraser McDonald, Henry Bertossi and Jillian Swartz.

Kingsdale Advisors Wes Hall, Ian Robertson, Himesh Gai and Anna Fernandes, Kelly Gorman and Christina Pellegrini provided proxy solicitation advice to TCI.

Gryphon Advisors Inc.’s Dexter John provided proxy solicitation services to CN.

About Allen McDonald Swartz LLP

Allen McDonald Swartz LLP provides strategic counsel, sophisticated business law advice and exceptional client service to Canadian and international clients. The firm’s lawyers — Jennifer Allen, Henry Bertossi, Brad Elberg, Fraser McDonald, Eden Oliver and Jillian Swartz — are all Bay Street veterans and provide their clients with experience and expertise that match BigLaw. Their clients include entrepreneurs, high-net-worth individuals, family-owned businesses, private and public companies, multi-national enterprises, law firms, independent committees, charities and not-for-profit organizations. The lawyers at AMS advise clients on mergers and acquisitions, reorganizations, privacy and anti-spam, financings, securities compliance and regulatory work, capital markets transactions, governance and business-critical commercial arrangements. The firm’s lawyers have experience across a diverse range of industries, including agribusiness, alternative energy, automotive, consumer products, event planning & hospitality, manufacturing, professional services (including dental, medical, and veterinary), media, sports & entertainment, technology, mining & natural resources and private equity.